From the good old-fashioned
Seeing patterns
Understanding what drives people into conspiracist thinking has inspired a number of scientific investigations. There’s one feature of the human brain that appears to bear quite a lot of the responsibility – the problem is, it’s also something we couldn’t manage without.
The brain is primed to look for patterns. As humans have evolved, this has proven extremely useful. It’s handy, for example, to learn that the color red often equals “danger”. It’s less handy to take the leap from, “Hmm, we appeared to have misplaced some ships,” to, “It must be an eldritch
“Our brain is constantly trying to make sense of the outside world. One way the brain accomplishes this goal is by detecting and learning patterns, which are essentially statistical regularities in the environment, because these patterns help the brain decide how to react or behave in order to survive,” Dr
The issues start to arise when this pattern-recognizing power goes into
A 2017 study published in the
One thing that came out of the study was a link between belief in some common conspiracies – including ones around climate change, the moon landing, and the
The researchers also explored a common observation in conspiracy spaces, that belief in one irrational theory is often indicative of belief in other, unrelated theories. If you can accept the idea that Barack Obama is a lizard in a human suit, it’s really just a short hop and a skip to believing that the US government had advance notice of 9/11.
“[A]cceptance of a conspiracy theory implies an increase in the extent to which people perceive patterns in world events, as reflected in the belief that instead of being a coincidence, many events that happen in the world are somehow causally related,” the authors posited.
To test this, they asked participants to read either a pro-conspiracy or anti-conspiracy article, before asking questions to assess their perception of a pattern in world events, finding that a correlation was present in those who’d been exposed to the conspiracy theory.
To summarize the findings of the study, the authors wrote, “We conclude that illusory pattern perception is a central cognitive ingredient of beliefs in conspiracy theories and supernatural phenomena.”
In the wake of conspiracy theories around the COVID-19 pandemic, this research became all the more timely, and subsequent studies have built on the ideas explored here.
One from the height of the pandemic in
“[Conspiracy theory] believers may find it hard to believe that a virus could originate randomly from the natural world because it does not fit with their preconceived view that events have a reason and usually a human or government influence behind it,” the authors explained.
The role of personality
Another key factor that has come to the fore in psychology studies of conspiracy beliefs is the role of personality.
Narcissism – the belief in one’s own superiority over others – has been found to be among the best psychological indicators of a predisposition toward believing in conspiracies. A
In a nutshell, narcissistic people will more readily believe that others are “out to get them”, meaning that conspiracies about sinister government plots or shady cabals controlling the media narrative fit right into their way of thinking.
Narcissists are also driven by a need to feel
Others may be drawn to conspiracies out of a desire to “watch the world burn” – basically, some people simply thrive on
Still, more research has suggested a link between
And some people may be initially drawn to conspiracies because they find them
What we know, and what we still don’t
A
Narcissism came up again, along with the three other personality traits that, with it, collectively form the so-called
What’s still tricky to pin down is which of the factors are causes and which are effects. Perhaps some people’s brains and
The authors of the review called for more research to address these open questions, with more varied samples. Above all, understanding the drivers that push people towards conspiracy theories – and remembering that these beliefs can have